Oil vs Acrylic Paint: What Are The Differences?

If you are a beginner painter, choosing between oil and acrylic paint can be confusing.

Understanding the difference between oil and acrylic paints is crucial for several reasons:

• Drying time
• Color and finish
• Ease of use and cleanup
• Surface compatibility
• Technique
• Longevity and durability
• Cost

These are a few of the differences between oil and acrylic paints that we will explore along with other important information.

Composition and Properties

Understanding the composition and properties of oil and acrylic paints is essential in guiding your selection process. Your artistic technique and the desired outcome play a significant role in determining which type of paint you’ll work with.

Base Ingredients

Oil paint is formulated based on natural oils, commonly linseed, walnut, or poppy, which act as the binder. The oils allow for a slow drying process, providing ample time for blending and layering.

In contrast, acrylic paint uses an acrylic polymer emulsion as its binder, resulting in a fast-drying medium. This property lets you work swiftly and is ideal for layering without long interruptions.

Pigment Composition

Both oil and acrylic paints contain pigments that provide color. These pigments are suspended in their respective binders—oil in oil paint and acrylic polymer in acrylic paint. While the pigments themselves can be similar, the binder affects the vibrancy and durability of the color.

Oil paint often retains a rich and vibrant color once dry, whereas acrylic paint can dry slightly darker than its wet state due to the clear acrylic binder becoming translucent.

Safety and Toxicity

When considering safety and toxicity, acrylic paints are generally non-toxic, making them suitable for a wide audience, including use in educational environments. However, be mindful of certain pigments that may still pose risks.

Oil paints, due to their natural oil binder, can have varying levels of toxicity, especially when considering solvents required for thinning and cleaning, which often emit strong fumes. Proper ventilation is essential when working with oil-based paints to ensure your safety.

According to mountsinai.org, hydrocarbons are the primary poisonous ingredient in oil paints.

They also say:

“Some oil paints have heavy metals such as lead, mercury, cobalt, and barium added as pigment. These heavy metals can cause additional poisoning if swallowed in large amounts.”

Application and Techniques

When considering oil and acrylic paints, your technique and the medium’s properties dictate the application process. Each has distinct characteristics that affect how you manipulate the paint and what surfaces you can apply it to.

Consistency and Mixing

Oil paints are oil-based and have a buttery and thick consistency, which can be altered using solvents like turpentine or linseed oil. The mixing of oils often feels smooth, and you can achieve a range of textures and transparencies.

Acrylics, on the other hand, are water-based; they can be thinned with water or acrylic mediums to alter viscosity. They dry to a plastic-like consistency, making it convenient for you to mix and fast to set up on your palette.

Blending and Layering

Because of its extended drying time, oil paint allows for more flexible blending techniques; you can work on a painting for several days and still manipulate the existing layers.

Acrylics dry quickly, which reduces the blendable window but allows for rapid layering. You can use a retarder with acrylics to extend the blending time. Both mediums allow for glazing and building up texture, but the approach and time frame you have for working with them vary.

Appropriate Surfaces

Your choice of surface plays a crucial role in the application process. Oil paints adhere well to surfaces prepared with gesso, and they’re commonly used on canvas or linen. It’s important that the surface is primed correctly to prevent oil from seeping through.

Acrylic paint is more versatile regarding surfaces; it can bond to a wide variety, including paper, wood, fabric, canvas board, and more. While less preparation is needed for acrylics, using gesso can enhance the texture and improve the paint’s adhesion.

Drying Time and Curing

In your journey with oil and acrylic paints, understanding the specifics of drying time and the curing process is crucial. Oils offer the luxury of extended workability, while acrylics bring forth the benefit of quick layering.

Factors Influencing Drying Time

The time it takes for your paint to dry can be affected by:

• Environmental conditions: Higher humidity and cooler temperatures can prolong drying time, whereas lower humidity and warmer temperatures typically speed it up.
• Paint type:
  • Acrylics: Acrylic paint dries rapidly, usually becoming touch-dry within minutes to hours depending on the thickness of the application.
  • Oils: Oil paint dries significantly slower, often taking days to become tack-free. Curing, however, can take weeks to months as it relies on oxidation, a process influenced by exposure to air.
• Mediums used:
  • For oils: The addition of mediums like turpentine, linseed oil, or safflower can alter the drying time. For example:
    • Adding turpentine speeds up drying.
    • Using linseed oil extends working time.
    • Safflower oil is a medium-drying oil, often used to maintain paint consistency.

Varnishing and Preservation

Varnishing is an integral part of the preservation process, and its timing is as follows:

• Acrylic Paintings: You can typically varnish an acrylic painting once it’s completely dry, which can be as soon as 24 to 48 hours after application.
• Oil Paintings: Due to their long curing process, oils require more patience. It’s recommended to wait at least six months before applying varnish to ensure the paint has cured properly.

Remember, varnish not only enhances the visual appeal of your painting but also offers a protective layer against dust, moisture, and UV light.

Aesthetic Outcomes

When you select a paint medium, the aesthetic outcomes on your finished artwork will differ notably. The finish and color properties imparted by oil and acrylic paints can affect the mood and visual impact of your work.

Finish Types

Oil paint typically produces a glossier finish with a notable sheen, due to the oil content. Over time, this sheen can contribute to a subtle depth and richness.

On the other hand, acrylic paint usually dries to a matte finish, though you can achieve a variety of finishes, from matte to satin to gloss, by using different mediums.

• Oil Paint:
  • Generally results in a smooth finish.
  • Offers a glossy look which adds to the perception of depth.
• Acrylic Paint:
  • Dries to a matte finish but can be modified using mediums.
  • Often presents a more consistently flat appearance.

Color Fidelity and Depth

The color fidelity and perceived depth of your painting can vary significantly between oil and acrylic paints. Oil paint colors tend to be more luminous and can retain their depth due to the layering possible with the slower drying time.

• Oil Paint:
  • Can appear more transparent, allowing for rich layering.
  • Offers a sense of depth due to the reflective properties of oil.
• Acrylic Paint:
  • Acrylics have a stable paint color that doesn’t yellow over time.
  • Matte acrylics diffuse light, reducing the perception of depth.

Maintenance and Durability

When considering oil and acrylic paints, maintenance and durability are crucial. Each painting medium requires specific care to maintain its appearance and structural integrity over time.

Cleaning Procedures

Oil Painting: You’ll need a solvent, such as turpentine or mineral spirits, for cleaning brushes after using oil paint. It’s vital to work in a well-ventilated area due to the fumes. For the painting’s surface, dust can be gently wiped away with a soft, dry brush.

Acrylics: They are water-soluble when wet, so brushes and spills clean up with just water, making it less hazardous and easier for you. Once dry, acrylics are resistant to water, which simplifies the cleaning of the finished work with a damp cloth for dust.

Longevity of Artworks

Oil paintings are known for their durability. The use of linseed oil as a binder creates a flexible and resistant paint film which, when cured, can last for centuries without significant changes in color or texture.

Acrylics, despite being a newer painting medium, also offer considerable durability. They are less prone to cracking over time compared to oils and can maintain their vibrancy as long as they’re protected from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures.

Comparative Advantages

When choosing between oil and acrylic paints, your preferences and the project’s requirements are pivotal. Each offers specific benefits pertaining to drying time, flexibility, and the nature of the base, which directly impact the painting process and the final results.

Oil Paint Benefits

• Extended Working Time: The oil in oil-based paints grants you a longer drying time. This allows ample opportunity for blending and layering, making it ideal for techniques that require gradual transitions and subtle gradations in color.
• Rich Texture: The thickness of oil paints provides a tactile quality to your work, achieving a level of depth that can enhance the visual appeal of your pieces.

Acrylic Paint Benefits

• Quick Drying: In contrast, acrylics are water-based paint and dry quickly, enabling you to work in rapid succession, layering without long waits.
• Versatile Supports: You can apply acrylic paint to a variety of surfaces without extensive preparation, which is not always the case with oil paints that require specific primers and supports.
• Ease and Convenience: Acrylic paints are more user-friendly, especially in terms of cleanup, as they do not require solvents; water is usually sufficient to wash brushes and other materials.

Materials and Accessories

When choosing materials for painting with oils or acrylics, you need to consider the compatibility and specific usage of brushes, tools, and painting media that work best with each paint type.

Choosing Brushes and Tools

For oil paint, select brushes that are sturdy and can handle the paint’s thickness and the use of solvents. Natural bristles, typically hog or sable, are preferred.

• Natural bristle brushes: Ideal for oil paints due to their durability and stiffness.

However, for acrylic paint, which is water-based, you can opt for a wider range of brushes:

• Synthetic brushes: These resist water and are a good match for the fast-drying nature of acrylics.
• Natural bristles: They also work, but can lose stiffness over time when used with acrylics.

Keep the following in mind when selecting tools:

1. Palette knives: Useful for mixing paint and applying it in thick layers.
2. Cleaning tools: Consider the solvents for oils (like paint thinner) and soapy water for acrylics.

Additional Painting Media

Each type of paint works best with certain painting mediums to manipulate texture, finish, and drying time.

For acrylics:

• Mediums: Enhance texture or provide a glossy or matte finish.
• Water: Can be used to thin paints but overuse can dilute the pigment.

For oil paints:

• Linseed oil: Commonly used to modify consistency and increase gloss.
• Solvents: Paint thinner and mineral spirits are used to thin paints and clean brushes.
• Varnish: Applied as a final coat to protect the painting and add a sheen.

When adding mediums, be conscious of the rule ‘fat over lean’ to avoid cracking, especially with oils. This means that each layer of paint should have more oil (fat) than the one below it to ensure proper drying and prevent the paint from cracking. Acrylics do not have this requirement due to their different composition and drying process.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, you’ll find concise answers to common queries regarding the nuances and practicalities of using oil and acrylic paints in your artwork.

What are the key differences in drying time between oil and acrylic paints?

Oil paints have a considerably longer drying time compared to acrylics, which can dry within minutes to hours. This allows for extended blending and workability with oil, while acrylics lend themselves to quicker layering techniques.

How do the finishes and textures compare between oil and acrylic painting?

Oil paints typically produce a richer, glossy finish with a smooth texture, while acrylics dry to a more matte finish and can vary in texture based on additives and the application technique used.

Is it possible and advisable to mix oil and acrylic paints in a single artwork?

Mixing oil and acrylic paints isn’t generally advised as they have different bases and drying times, which can affect adhesion and longevity of the artwork. However, some artists use both in a layered approach, applying acrylics as a base and oils on top after the acrylics have dried.

What are the main considerations when choosing between oil and acrylic for outdoor paintings?

For outdoor paintings, acrylics are often favored due to their quick drying time, reduced susceptibility to environmental variables, and minimal fading. Oils, while more susceptible to temperatures and humidity, are preferred for their blending capabilities and depth of color.

How does the longevity and durability of oil paintings compare to those done with acrylics?

Oil paintings are known for their durability and can maintain their vibrancy for centuries if properly cared for. Acrylics also have good longevity but are less resistant to cracking over time. Ultraviolet light and harsh environmental conditions can affect both mediums.

In terms of ease of use and cleanup, how do oil paints differ from acrylics?

Oil paints require solvents like turpentine for thinning and cleanup, which can be messy and necessitate careful handling. Acrylics are water-based, making them easier to clean up with soap and water and generally more user-friendly.

Sharing is caring!